Dollar General vs Family Dollar: Which Store Is Better for Penny Shopping?

Dollar General and Family Dollar are both discount chains with clearance programs, but their penny shopping opportunities differ substantially. Dollar General has a well-known formal penny program while Family Dollar, now merged with Dollar Tree, operates differently. Here’s what penny shoppers need to know.

Feature
Dollar General
Family Dollar
Penny Program
Formal (weekly Tuesday drops)
Informal (ad cycle markdowns)
Parent Company
Dollar General Corp
Dollar Tree Inc
US Store Count
19,000+
8,000+
Avg Penny Items per Cycle
20-50 items
5-20 items
Item Categories
Wide (health, toys, seasonal)
Primarily household, food
Resale Value
$8-$15 average
$4-$10 average
Store Layout
Organized by category
Varies widely
Competition Level
High in urban areas
Lower overall
Digital Tools
DG app with scanning
Limited app features
Seasonal Clearance
Excellent rotation
Good

The Verdict

Dollar General dominates for penny shopping due to its structured program, higher-value items, and far larger store network. Family Dollar is worth checking — particularly in smaller towns where competition is lower — but it should be a secondary stop after your Dollar General runs. Penny Flip focuses primarily on Dollar General penny lists where the ROI is consistently highest.

Get real-time penny drop alerts with profit data.

Paid members see penny drops the instant we detect them, plus estimated margins on every item. Free plan available.

Sign Up Free

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Family Dollar have a formal penny program?
Family Dollar does not have a formal penny program like Dollar General. Clearance items at Family Dollar are marked down through their weekly ad cycle, with some items reaching very low prices but not typically a single cent. The penny opportunities are less consistent and harder to predict.
Are Dollar General and Family Dollar owned by the same company?
No. Dollar General is an independent company (Dollar General Corporation). Family Dollar was acquired by Dollar Tree Inc. in 2015. This means Family Dollar and Dollar Tree share corporate infrastructure, which affects their clearance and markdown strategies.

More Comparisons

1c

Get real-time penny drop alerts

Paid members get penny drops the instant we detect them. Free plan available — no credit card required.

Sign Up Free