Amazon FBA vs eBay: Where to Sell Penny Items for Maximum Profit

Choosing between Amazon FBA and eBay is one of the biggest decisions for penny resellers. Each platform has strengths depending on product category, volume, and your preferred workflow. Here’s how they compare.

Feature
Amazon FBA
eBay
Total Fees
20-35% of sale price
13-15% of sale price
Shipping Handling
Amazon handles everything
You ship each order
Time to Sell
1-7 days (high demand items)
1-14 days average
Monthly Subscription
$39.99/mo (Professional)
$7.95/mo (Starter Store)
Customer Base
300M+ active accounts
130M+ active buyers
Returns Rate
Higher (easy returns)
Lower
Best For
Health, Beauty, Grocery
Electronics, Toys, Niche
Gated Categories
Many restricted categories
Few restrictions
Listing Effort
Low (match existing listing)
Medium (create listing)
Profit per Item (avg)
$5-$10 after fees
$8-$15 after fees

The Verdict

For penny items, eBay generally delivers higher per-item profit due to lower fees. However, Amazon FBA saves significant time on shipping and customer service, making it better for high-volume sellers. The ideal strategy is to sell health and beauty items on Amazon FBA (where demand is highest) and electronics, toys, and niche items on eBay (where margins are better). Penny Flip shows marketplace-specific profit estimates to help you decide.

Get real-time penny drop alerts with profit data.

Paid members see penny drops the instant we detect them, plus estimated margins on every item. Free plan available.

Sign Up Free

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Amazon FBA worth the higher fees?
For high-volume sellers, yes. FBA saves 10-15 minutes per order in packing and shipping time. If you sell 100+ items per month, the time savings easily justify the higher fees. For low-volume sellers, eBay’s lower fees make more sense.
Can I sell on both platforms?
Yes, and many successful penny resellers do. Send health and beauty items to FBA and list electronics and niche items on eBay. This maximizes your total revenue and reduces platform dependency.

More Comparisons

Dollar General vs Dollar Tree: Which Is Better for Penny Shopping?

eBay vs Mercari: Which Platform for Penny Item Resale?

Related Penny Shopping Resources

Penny Shopping for Beginners

Start here if you're new to penny shopping.

Penny Deal Products

100+ product categories with profit analysis.

Seasonal Penny Deals

Calendar of seasonal clearance opportunities.

1c

Get real-time penny drop alerts

Paid members get penny drops the instant we detect them. Free plan available — no credit card required.

Sign Up Free